POETIC JUSTICE: WHEN MORALITY WRITES ITS OWN POETR

“When Character Becomes Consequence.” — Adv. C.V. Manuvilsan

WHAT WHEN MORALITY WRITES ITS OWN POETR? WE CALL IT  POETIC JUSTICE??

By Adv. C.V. Manuvilsan

• The Seduction of Symmetry

Why does it feel satisfying when a corrupt man collapses under his own corruption?

Why does the betrayer getting betrayed feel… correct?

Not just legally correct.

Emotionally correct.

That feeling — that deep inner nod — is what we call poetic justice.

The phrase was coined by the 17th-century English critic

Thomas Rymer.

He argued that in drama, virtue must be rewarded and vice must be punished — not arbitrarily, but with artistic proportion. Justice, in literature, should move with rhythm.

Poetry has structure.

Drama has design.

Stories have symmetry.

Real life? Not always.

In reality, the wicked sometimes prosper and the innocent suffer.

But in stories, the universe behaves better.

That difference — between chaotic life and structured narrative — is the birthplace of poetic justice.

And perhaps, the birthplace of our longing.

 

• The Architecture of Moral Elegance

Poetic justice is not about rhyme. It is about moral geometry.

It occurs when the punishment fits not just the crime — but the character flaw that caused the crime.

Consider Macbeth.

Macbeth kills for power.

What destroys him? Not merely a sword.

It is paranoia — born from ambition itself.

Or take Othello.

Jealousy becomes both motive and executioner.

The flaw contains the seed of the fall.

That is poetic justice.

It is justice that grows organically from within.

The trap-setter falls into his own trap.

The manipulator is undone by manipulation.

The liar collapses under layers of his own falsehood.

In law, justice is procedural.

In poetry, justice is proportional.

The law punishes because rules are broken.

Poetic justice punishes because inner imbalance demands correction.

One is institutional.

The other is aesthetic.

 

•  Is the Universe a Courtroom or a Poem?

Now comes the unsettling question.

Does poetic justice reflect reality — or merely our hunger for symmetry?

Are we witnessing a moral cosmos…

Or projecting one?

Human cognition is wired to detect patterns. Randomness disturbs us. We instinctively impose structure on chaos. When events align morally, we feel relief. When they do not, we call it tragedy.

But the universe itself?

It operates by physics, not plot.

Yet storytelling insists on closure. On consequence. On narrative balance.

So what is poetic justice really?

Perhaps it is not proof that the universe is moral.

Perhaps it is proof that humans are narrative beings.

We do not merely want justice.

We want justice that makes sense.

Justice that feels earned.

Justice that completes a story.

And that longing reveals something profound.

We are creatures who believe that morality should not only be correct — it should be beautiful.

 

• Closing Echo

Poetic justice is where ethics meets aesthetics.

It is the point where consequence becomes choreography.

It reminds us th
at law governs society,

but stories govern the human soul.

The real world may not always resolve like a well-written tragedy.

But our insistence on poetic justice tells us something essential:

We are not satisfied with order alone.

We crave meaning.

And meaning, like poetry, demands proportion.

cvmanuvilsan@gmail.com
9846288877